CureZone.com
   Home > Article Index > Alkalosis > Cardiovascular Disease

Go Back

Reprinted from:
mercola.com/2002/mar/30/doctors_shame.htm

Shame: A Major Reason Why Most Medical Doctors Don't Change Their Views

By Frank Davidoff



Shame: A Major Reason Why Most Medical Doctors Don't Change Their Views
By Frank Davidoff

http://www.mercola.com/2002/mar/30/doctors_shame.htm

In the 1960s the results of a large randomized controlled study by the University Group Diabetes Program showed that tolbutamide, virtually the only blood sugar lowering agent available at the time in pill form, was associated with a significant increase in mortality in patients who developed myocardial infarction.

The obvious response from the medical profession should have been gratitude: here was an important way to improve the safety of clinical practice. But in fact the response was doubt, outrage, even legal proceedings against the investigators; the controversy went on for years.

Why?

An important clue surfaced at the annual meeting of the American Diabetes Association soon after the study was published. During the discussion a practitioner stood up and said he simply could not, and would not, accept the findings, because admitting to his patients that he had been using an unsafe treatment would shame him in their eyes. Other examples of such reactions to improvement efforts are not hard to find.

Indeed, it is arguable that shame is the universal dark side of improvement.

After all, improvement means that, however good your performance has been, it is not as good as it could be. As such, the experience of shame helps to explain why improvement, which ought to be a "no brainer", is generally such a slow and difficult process.

What is it about shame that makes it so hard to deal with? Along with embarrassment and guilt, shame is one of the emotions that motivate moral behavior. Current thinking suggests that shame is so devastating because it goes right to the core of a person's identity, making them feel exposed, inferior, degraded; it leads to avoidance, to silence.

The enormous power of shame is apparent in the adoption of shaming by many human rights organizations as their principal lever for social change; on the flip side lies the obvious social corrosiveness of "shameless" behavior.

Despite its potential importance in medical life, shame has received little attention in the medical literature: a search on the term shame in Medline in November 2001 yielded only 947 references out of the millions indexed. In a sense, shame is the "elephant in the room": something so big and disturbing that we don't even see it, despite the fact that we keep bumping into it.

An important exception to this blindness to medical shame is a paper published in 1987 by the psychiatrist Aaron Lazare which reminded us that patients commonly see their diseases as defects, inadequacies, or shortcomings, and that visits to doctors' surgeries and hospitals involve potentially humiliating physical and psychological exposure.

Patients respond by avoiding the healthcare system, withholding information, complaining, and suing. Doctors too can feel shamed in medical encounters, which Lazare suggests contributes to dissatisfaction with clinical practice.

Indeed, much of the extreme distress of doctors who are sued for malpractice appears to be attributable to the shame rather than to the financial losses. Also, who can doubt that a major concern underlying the controversy currently raging over mandatory reporting of medical errors is the fear of being shamed?

Doctors may, in fact, be particularly vulnerable to shame, since they are self-selected for perfectionism when they choose to enter the profession.

Moreover, the use of shaming as punishment for shortcomings and "moral errors" committed by medical students and trainees such as lack of sufficient dedication, hard work, and a proper reverence for role obligations probably contributes further to the extreme sensitivity of doctors to shaming.

What are the lessons here for those working to improve the quality and safety of medical care?

Firstly, we should recognize that shame is a powerful force in slowing or preventing improvement and that unless it is confronted and dealt with progress in improvement will be slow. Secondly, we should also recognize that shame is a fundamental human emotion and not about to go away. Once these ideas are understood, the work of mitigating and managing shame can flourish.

This work has, of course, been under way for some time. The move away from "cutting off the tail of the performance curve" that is, getting rid of bad apples towards "shifting the whole curve" as the basic strategy in quality improvement and the recognition that medical error results as much from malfunctioning systems as from incompetent practitioners are important developments in this regard.

They have helped to minimize challenges to the integrity of healthcare workers and support the transformation of medicine from a culture of blame to a culture of safety.

But quality improvement has another powerful tool for managing shame. Bringing issues of quality and safety out of the shadows can, by itself, remove some of the sting associated with improvement. After all, how shameful can these issues be if they are being widely shared and openly discussed?

Here is where reports by public bodies and journals like Quality and Safety in Health Care come in. More specifically, such a journal supports three major elements autonomy, mastery, and connectedness that motivate people to learn and improve, bolstering their competence and their sense of self worth, and thus serving as antidotes to shame.

British Medical Journal 2002;324:623-624 March 16, 2002




DR. MERCOLA'S COMMENT:

I believe this is a central issue to the transformation of the medical paradigm.

It never occurred to me that shame could be a strongly motivating influence preventing many physicians from changing their previous practice habits.

Shifting them would imply that they were wrong in the past and that is something that most physicians seem to have a great deal of problems with and the shaming seems central to the cause.

Fortunately, EFT would be a wonderful tool to heal this wound. The practical challenge, of course, will be to arrange for the physicians to receive this treatment so they can progress forward with truthful information that will really serve their patients well.

Reprinted from:
mercola.com/2002/mar/30/doctors_shame.htm

Related
News
Liver Flush - Quackery or Valuable Remedy  Apr 18 2003
HOW TO LOWER YOUR CHOLESTEROL  Aug 30 2002
New cholesterol guidelines for converting healthy people into patients  Jun 15 2002
The Cholesterol Myths  Jun 15 2002
My husband's full recovery from lung tumor and massive heart attack without drugs/chemo/surgery  Jun 07 2002
Hospital Drug-Error Trends Continue  May 29 2002
This is what you will bring into your life  May 29 2002
Raw Eating - A book by A.T. Hovannessian (Aterhov)  May 21 2002
Caffeine, even in small doses, may hurt arteries  May 18 2002
Want a Healthy Heart? Drink Water  May 16 2002
Fluoride and Aluminum - toxic combination of fluoroaluminum complex   May 15 2002
The Nocebo Effect: Placebo's Evil Twin  May 15 2002
HYPERTHERMIA - The "COLD SHEET" Treatment   May 05 2002
Ailments & Herbal remedies - Dr. Richard Schulze  May 04 2002
Incurables Program - Dr. Richard Schulze  May 04 2002
Herbal Formulas - Dr. Richard Schulze  May 04 2002
Patient Handbook - Dr. Richard Schulze  May 04 2002
Study: Folk remedy used in India cuts cholesterol  May 03 2002
Excitotoxins - MSG and Aspartame  May 03 2002
Exercise Can Lower Risk of Death from Stroke  May 01 2002
Mercury fillings are affecting dentists  May 01 2002
British group says patients can refuse treatment  Apr 30 2002
Minnesota - the first US State to offer Freedom of Choice  Apr 30 2002
The Signs of Inner Peace  Apr 30 2002
WHO announces urgent meeting on new food cancer scare  Apr 29 2002
A Simple Guide To Herbs  Apr 26 2002
Cooked tomatoes 'better for you than raw'  Apr 26 2002
Angry Young Men At Greater Risk Of Heart Disease  Apr 26 2002
Dr. Atkins suffered cardiac arrest  Apr 25 2002
Understanding the Healing Crisis  Apr 25 2002
Virgin Olive Oil May Reduce Cholesterol Damage  Apr 24 2002
Fish Oil Cuts Risk of Sudden Death  Apr 24 2002
Beans and Peas Can Cut Heart Disease Risk  Dec 15 2001

Back To Top




 
Google Advertisement



 
Google Advertisement



 
Google Advertisement



 
Google Advertisement


 

Donate to CureZone

0.1400 sec
IP 34.232.63.94