Just a little update, I filed a dispute with Paypal over the charge with Apothecaryco.com. Apothecaryco.com has yet to respond. Either they have gone on a very long vacation, or are officially out of business.
In the meantime, I placed an order with John and Magnascent.com for one 4oz. bottle of 2%. It arrived within four days with a gift of two extra .5oz bottles. Really nice touch. I'm going to gift them to two slightly sickly loved ones in my life.